Apple Cider Donut Oreos

-
"Another Day, Another Donut!"
Fall is here! Hello crinkly leaves, pumpkin spice, corn maze anxiety, and, just introduced this past July, Apple Cider Donut Oreos! The Donut Cooperation of America (yes, that's a thing) first promoted the apple cider donut in 1951, and they've heralded fall ever since! Nabisco has done at least four donut Oreos at this point, and the expectations are HIGH. We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS! 

Creativity
V - Mad creative! Every autumn, I "fall" hard for all things pumpkin spice and sometimes need reminding that the season encompasses a myriad of flavors and sensations. Apple cider donuts bring back a clear memory of a really nice day at the apple orchard with my family. Nabisco's working with such a specific fall flavor feels unique and personal in the best way possible. 

B - I'll give it points here. I am just glad to see something other than pumpkin!

Execution
B - Not going to lie, I was pretty disappointed overall with these. I think because I was so hyped for them, I was that much more sad about them when they didn't meet my expectations. The Oreos did not remind me of an apple cider donut...what it did remind me of was apple cinnamon Quaker oatmeal... like, it's seriously a dead ringer for those breakfast packets (albeit crunchier). Probably something about the artificial apple? 

V - The execution is funky. The creme is softer and messier than the norm and its distribution is slightly different for each Oreo. Because the creme is ultra-sweet, each cookie has its own flavor profile, for better or worse! I had about four cookies that had just the right balance of apple and cinnamon though and it made it all worth it! I am used to Oreos being militant in their cookie to creme ratio, but I don't hate the homemade vibe.

Does it Sparkle?
V - It's not offensive. The cookies and creme are all the same beige color. I think Nabisco could have done some artificial-chemical magic (we don't claim to be a health blog) to give the cookies a deeper, reddish hue. Fall is the season of colors, after all! 

B - It was ok but didn't dazzle. Even the packaging was just sort of blah. But in a burgundy-mustard-hued blah. Could've done something cool with the cover art at least. Maybe a fall collage?  A pile of leaves? Something to capture all the excitement of an orchard.

Pairing
V - Apple cider donut Oreos are sweet, so they work well with a "hoppy" beer. I recommend a seasonal pumpkin beer because fall flavors all just kind of work together. Black tea or a bougie fall something from your favorite local coffee shop will also pair beautifully. 

B - We also talked about pairing it with hot mulled wine. I love the aesthetic of it. Like the kind served in mugs with the little cinnamon sticks. 

Buy Again?
V - Maple Oreos are still my favorite autumnal releases so far, so I do not think I would buy them again. They are good though! 

B - No; I will just eat my oatmeal and feel like it was a better choice. 

The Ratings!
Creativity

Execution

Aesthetics

Pairing

Buy Again?

Overall


Want More Oreos? Follow our insta at werateoreosbv and make sure to subscribe!

Comments

  1. JessOctober 7, 2021 at 8:49 AM

    Such a bummer to see this cookie fall flat. It could have been great!
    @B I was also very disappointed in the packaging. You’d think all that nabisco money could pay a decent designer to do something more exciting for a release like this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. AnonymousOctober 7, 2021 at 9:14 AM

      Hey, Jess! Thank you for your comment :) They are fun to try for the novelty, but the Maple Oreos set the bar high for me!

      Delete
    2. BOctober 29, 2021 at 9:08 PM

      LOL - *fall* flat - I see what you did there... And as for happier packaging news... Stay tuned for our next installment!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Please share your thoughts!

Popular posts from this blog

Space Dunk Oreos

-
Image
Killer Oreos From Outer Space January 29th, 2024, in a galaxy far far away, Nabisco's Space Dunk Oreos hit shelves! With probe Odysseus landing on the moon (the first one in decades to do so) in February and the rare eclipse happening in April, we have been partying to the moon and back! Maybe we'll finally get to meet the aliens! While this is not the first marshmallow-flavored space Oreo, it is the first to add pop rocks to the creme. Do the Space Dunk Oreos live up to the 2024 intergalactic hype? Let's find out together. We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS! Creativity V- Pop rocks and marshmallow as a flavor combo is certainly unique! If you liked it (like I did), then the risk paid off and you might find it creative. If you didn't like it, it may come across as a bizarre pairing that is more focused on being unique or edgy than flavorful. I am giving it creativity points because the theme and flavors were wacky, but it worked! I also love how, for this edition, they el...
Read more

Black and White Oreos

-
Image
Black and White ! In December 2023, Nabisco first revealed the black and white Oreos. No grey area here! Maybe I am overly free-associating but for me, black and white conveys classy old movies, Transatlantic accents, noir detectives, and incredible style! Did Nabisco evoke such grandeur? Let's find out together! We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS! Creativity B-  OK, s o the idea was *almost* there for this. As a first impression, it sounds cool and the cookies themselves look classy as hell. But unfortunately, the execution wasn't all there to earn any points from me here. They could've taken the flavor and name a step (or two or three) further. V- The black and white Oreos are simple. We have vanilla cookie sandwiches with a swirl of white and chocolate creme on the inside. For full creativity points, Nabisco would need to incorporate the black-and-white concept into a grand theme! Maybe each package could have had fun facts about zebras (Nabisco should totally hire me as ...
Read more

Super Mario Oreos

-
Image
Super Mario Let's a-go! In July 2023, Nabisco released Super Mario Oreos! The flavor is classic, while the cookies have designs with all your favorite Mario characters. Super Mario is one of the most iconic pop culture icons of all time. One thing I've never understood though-how does Bowser kidnap Princess Peach one day, and then go go-karting with her as a friend the next? The world may never know! As established Oreo bloggers, we have high standards. We hope that each Oreo captures the strange, colorful magic of the Mario universe. Let's find out together. We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS!   Creativity V-  The Mario movie was a summer hit! Mario started hopping on Wrigglers and Yoshis in  Super Mario World  in 1990 ,  and it's no surprise that Nabisco is hopping on this bandwagon now! And I love it. It's fun when people come together to enjoy a pop culture moment. Unfortunately, I can't give full creativity points for such blatant capitalism. Maybe I would be...
Read more