Mint To Be

-
Mint to Be
Who doesn't love Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream? We have Marilyn Ricketts, an English culinary student, to thank for inventing this delightful flavor in 1973. Originally called "Mint Royale," Ricketts' creation placed at a competition to provide a new ice cream flavor for Princess Anne's wedding at Westminster Abby. In continuation of Ricketts' creative spirit, Nabisco released Baskin-Robbins Mint Chocolate Chip Oreos this August 2019. Would these cookies meet royal standards? We'll find out! We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS!

Flavor Creativity
B- Mint is a classic flavor. The ice cream flavor - not so much. At least in a non-ice cream dessert.

 V- So creative! I see mint chocolate chip everything, but mint chocolate chip ice cream is something special.

Flavor Execution
V- It's very good! It tasted a little more like a Thin Mint than creamy Baskin-Robbins ice cream, but they had lovely bits of chocolate and mint in the creme that were an absolute delight. Sometimes too much mint puts my taste buds in toothpaste territory, but not these cookies! The balance is perfect.

B- Well done, Oreo. I agree with V in that it's not really as much like Baskin Robins as it is the girl scout cookie. It tastes just like a thin mint! But this version has better texture and is less dry imo. Haven't tried to freeze them yet, so don't worry - the two are probably not interchangeable.  

Does it Sparkle?
B- So sparkly. 

V- Yes! The big scoop of ice cream on the package reminds us that these are ice cream flavored, rather than just regular mint. It piqued my curiosity (honestly an easy thing to do) and even made me a little nostalgic for this simple childhood staple.  

 Pairing
V- Orange Juice! Just kidding, don't do that. The mint and chocolate flavors pair wonderfully with stouts and porters. 

B- Chocolate and mint are a time-honored pairing. It would be good as an after-dinner cookie; cleanse the palate, ya know?


Buy Again?
B- Yes. I like mint and I like these cookies even better. Plus they're cheaper than other alternatives including the girl scout version or a double scoop at B.R. 

V- No. I've never been a huge mint fan, as good as these are! They also took AGES to appear on the shelves down in small-town Ohio. 

 Final Thoughts
V- Yes! These are good cookies! They are a perfect balance of familiar and creative.

B- No complaints here. And no offense to any of the industries mentioned. Disclaimer: I am just a consumer and this blog is not paid. 

 Flavor Creativity

Flavor Execution

Aesthetics

Pairing


Buyability

Overall



Want more Oreos? Subscribe above, and follow us on Insta at werateoreosbv ðŸ˜Š

Comments

  1. FrogtownLindaOctober 25, 2019 at 4:26 PM

    Ohhhh can't wait to try these, they sound delightful to this GS Thin Mint fan!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. VOctober 25, 2019 at 5:36 PM

      Yes! Your friendly Oreo experts highly recommend them :)

      Delete

Post a Comment

Please share your thoughts!

Popular posts from this blog

Space Dunk Oreos

-
Image
Killer Oreos From Outer Space January 29th, 2024, in a galaxy far far away, Nabisco's Space Dunk Oreos hit shelves! With probe Odysseus landing on the moon (the first one in decades to do so) in February and the rare eclipse happening in April, we have been partying to the moon and back! Maybe we'll finally get to meet the aliens! While this is not the first marshmallow-flavored space Oreo, it is the first to add pop rocks to the creme. Do the Space Dunk Oreos live up to the 2024 intergalactic hype? Let's find out together. We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS! Creativity V- Pop rocks and marshmallow as a flavor combo is certainly unique! If you liked it (like I did), then the risk paid off and you might find it creative. If you didn't like it, it may come across as a bizarre pairing that is more focused on being unique or edgy than flavorful. I am giving it creativity points because the theme and flavors were wacky, but it worked! I also love how, for this edition, they el...
Read more

Black and White Oreos

-
Image
Black and White ! In December 2023, Nabisco first revealed the black and white Oreos. No grey area here! Maybe I am overly free-associating but for me, black and white conveys classy old movies, Transatlantic accents, noir detectives, and incredible style! Did Nabisco evoke such grandeur? Let's find out together! We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS! Creativity B-  OK, s o the idea was *almost* there for this. As a first impression, it sounds cool and the cookies themselves look classy as hell. But unfortunately, the execution wasn't all there to earn any points from me here. They could've taken the flavor and name a step (or two or three) further. V- The black and white Oreos are simple. We have vanilla cookie sandwiches with a swirl of white and chocolate creme on the inside. For full creativity points, Nabisco would need to incorporate the black-and-white concept into a grand theme! Maybe each package could have had fun facts about zebras (Nabisco should totally hire me as ...
Read more

Super Mario Oreos

-
Image
Super Mario Let's a-go! In July 2023, Nabisco released Super Mario Oreos! The flavor is classic, while the cookies have designs with all your favorite Mario characters. Super Mario is one of the most iconic pop culture icons of all time. One thing I've never understood though-how does Bowser kidnap Princess Peach one day, and then go go-karting with her as a friend the next? The world may never know! As established Oreo bloggers, we have high standards. We hope that each Oreo captures the strange, colorful magic of the Mario universe. Let's find out together. We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS!   Creativity V-  The Mario movie was a summer hit! Mario started hopping on Wrigglers and Yoshis in  Super Mario World  in 1990 ,  and it's no surprise that Nabisco is hopping on this bandwagon now! And I love it. It's fun when people come together to enjoy a pop culture moment. Unfortunately, I can't give full creativity points for such blatant capitalism. Maybe I would be...
Read more