Coca-Cola Oreos In September 2024, Coca-Cola Oreos hit the shelves! The secret formula for this iconic drink is locked deep in a vault in Atlanta. Could Nabisco even hope to recreate this classic without it? Let's find out together. We are B and V and WE RATE OREOS! Creativity V- All the points! I've used Coca-Cola in baking to enrich my cocoa powder, but I've never thought to attempt to make a dessert actually taste like pop. It's truly a novel idea. B- Creative, for sure, but t hese are...weird. The package honestly smells like soda pop when you open it, like if it had exploded and dried out in the car. Execution V- The execution is rough! The top red cookie tastes like Coca-Cola, then you have regular creme with pop rocks, and the bottom cookie is chocolate. I loved the Coca-Cola cookie and I always appreciate Oreos with pop rocks in the creme. Then, the chocolate cookie pops in and messes with the whole flavor! It adds this weird heaviness to everything and m...